Welcome to Krazy Kats - a friendly informal online community discussing life issues that we care about. Open 24/7 for chat & chill. Come and join us!

The Video of the Week now showing on Light After Life's portal page is: 'The Day I Died' (BBC Documentary).

Latest topics

» Silly Endings.
by Stardust Today at 07:29

» Keep a Word - Delete a Word
by Stardust Today at 07:25

» Books
by Stardust Yesterday at 18:35

» Cosmic beauty
by Stardust Yesterday at 11:26

» Blogthings: The Easter egg personality test.
by Kitkat Yesterday at 10:29

» Blogthings: What part of Spring are you?
by Stardust Yesterday at 10:13

» Nature
by Stardust Yesterday at 09:52

» So you think you know cats... read on
by Stardust Yesterday at 09:43

» Feather by the sea.
by Stardust Yesterday at 08:59

by Kitkat 22/3/2018, 13:09

» Wild Scotland
by Stardust 22/3/2018, 09:49

» Blogthings: what forest animal are you?
by Whiskers 21/3/2018, 16:40

» Bureaucats: Whiskers in the Workplace
by Whiskers 21/3/2018, 15:45

» Wildlife - lions eat the poacher
by Whiskers 21/3/2018, 15:43

» Wildlife - San Francisco to ban sale of fur
by Stardust 21/3/2018, 11:48

» The Beast from the East?
by Stardust 21/3/2018, 10:44

» Delicious and nutritious
by Stardust 21/3/2018, 10:19

» Wildlife - death of Sudan, last male White Northern Rhino
by Stardust 21/3/2018, 08:55

» Guess the word
by Whiskers 21/3/2018, 08:28

» April Fools
by Stardust 21/3/2018, 07:57

» Your man with the glasses ...
by Kitkat 20/3/2018, 13:36

» Message in a bottle
by Stardust 20/3/2018, 09:39

» Stardust on the Moon
by Stardust 20/3/2018, 09:25

» Stephen Hawking's warnings: What he predicted for the future
by Feather 16/3/2018, 22:40

» The cartoon thread.
by Whiskers 11/3/2018, 13:43

» Upper Back Pain
by Kitkat 10/3/2018, 16:14

» [solved] Yahoo Mail down - again!
by Kitkat 9/3/2018, 23:00

» Concerns with Wikipedia (and "filter bubbles") - Guerrilla Skeptics at Large
by Kitkat 3/3/2018, 23:29

» Wonderful images - fabulous music
by bimbow 1/3/2018, 17:23

» The Beast from the East
by Kitkat 1/3/2018, 14:01

» MPs call for ESA death statistics to be published (Calum's List)
by Kitkat 28/2/2018, 17:06

» Invasion of the sex-craved spiders! EEK!
by lar-lar 25/2/2018, 21:32

» The Irish Thread
by lar-lar 25/2/2018, 21:30

» Daughter fundraising to save her terminally ill mother
by Jamboree 18/2/2018, 11:53

» Kitkat's KK Blog
by Kitkat 15/2/2018, 21:36

» Poetry from the heart.
by Jamboree 12/2/2018, 07:46

» A Day in The Life of a Dictator - Documentary
by Jamboree 12/2/2018, 07:21

» A coconut in a coffin?
by Whiskers 9/2/2018, 20:35

» Limericks
by bimbow 8/2/2018, 21:22

» Is there a Cathy in the place?
by Kitkat 1/2/2018, 19:17

» Chinese New Year
by Stardust 1/2/2018, 14:17

» What's your emergency?
by Whiskers 27/1/2018, 13:09

» YouTube free-loading vlogger gets a much needed lesson in reality
by Whiskers 22/1/2018, 20:17

» Three-month-old baby says "hello"
by Kitkat 13/1/2018, 15:00

» 60 Christmas traditions around the world
by Kitkat 30/12/2017, 21:58

» Simon's Cat
by Kitkat 26/12/2017, 16:27

» A new(ish) song for Christmas.
by Whiskers 24/12/2017, 13:49

» Merry Christmas
by Whiskers 24/12/2017, 13:37

» The Christmas Thread
by Kitkat 20/12/2017, 21:22

» A reader's response to your article on food waste
by Whiskers 18/12/2017, 14:35

» Downward Dog
by Kitkat 4/12/2017, 21:35

» A very young Bee Gees treat
by Whiskers 29/11/2017, 16:35

» Prime cheek!
by Kitkat 28/11/2017, 09:32

» The life and achievements of Dr Elsie Inglis
by Kitkat 26/11/2017, 09:14

» Hidden disabilities: Pain beneath the surface
by Kitkat 21/11/2017, 21:20

» Scary photos
by Kitkat 19/11/2017, 12:50

» The 7-year-old neuroscientist wowing the internet
by Kitkat 16/11/2017, 10:03

» The cat killer stalking suburbia
by Whiskers 6/11/2017, 15:53

» It's that time again .....
by Kitkat 29/10/2017, 00:21

» Happy Halloween!
by Stardust 25/10/2017, 08:37

» Love makes the world go round
by Stardust 25/10/2017, 08:00

» Need help with homework (Hall Effect)
by Kitkat 24/10/2017, 12:18

» Well hello there!
by Whiskers 23/10/2017, 23:53

» Madeleine McCann investigation continues ...
by Whiskers 23/10/2017, 23:43

» Famous Youtubers... Do you watch them? Do you dislike them?
by Jamboree 23/10/2017, 00:44

» Control your television with any object
by loner55 16/10/2017, 10:32

» Fahrenheit 451
by loner55 16/10/2017, 10:26

» HAPPY BIRTHDAY to Feather!
by Jamboree 15/10/2017, 17:43

» A walk through Dominica, hours after Hurricane Maria
by Kitkat 15/10/2017, 12:48

» SKEPS Forum
by Kitkat 8/10/2017, 22:00

» Quotes about Lifestye
by Whiskers 7/10/2017, 15:25

» Songs from the heart
by Stardust 20/9/2017, 20:55

» Bodies of 'hundreds' of children buried in mass grave
by mac 19/9/2017, 12:25

» Psychics didn't foresee THAT coming!
by mac 16/9/2017, 15:14

» Number 7777
by Kitkat 14/9/2017, 14:10

» 'Messy' mum barred from pub
by Stardust 11/9/2017, 16:17

» [solved] Multiquote ?
by Whiskers 11/9/2017, 11:13

» Why men are happier people???
by Stardust 8/9/2017, 20:10

» A Granma's Anagrams
by Stardust 8/9/2017, 19:49

» Pink rainbow
by Stardust 8/9/2017, 15:46

» Barking mad!
by Stardust 8/9/2017, 15:44

» Surviving in Libya
by Kitkat 7/9/2017, 22:52

» The Forum Café
by Kitkat 7/9/2017, 14:53

» Hurricane Irma
by Kitkat 7/9/2017, 12:22

» Struggling To Login
by Kitkat 6/9/2017, 17:41

» Kitchen bat chase video goes viral
by Kitkat 6/9/2017, 17:21

» 10 things we didn't know last week ...
by Whiskers 4/9/2017, 14:31

» End of Summer Drinks
by EndoWarriror 1/9/2017, 13:53

» Bruce Forsyth dies aged 89
by EndoWarriror 1/9/2017, 13:34

» [solved] Notifications re new topics & posts on the forum
by Kitkat 1/9/2017, 13:23

» [solved] New forum design
by Jamboree 23/8/2017, 13:03

» [solved] Photobucket
by Jamboree 10/8/2017, 02:36

» Hi from Brin
by Whiskers 6/8/2017, 12:14

» Delusions
by Kitkat 30/7/2017, 12:19

by Jamboree 25/7/2017, 16:03

» [solved] Photobucket no longer free ...
by Kitkat 8/7/2017, 11:05

» [solved] Problems logging in from your mobile, iPad or tablet?
by Kitkat 5/7/2017, 13:05

» Protest March through London
by Kitkat 1/7/2017, 17:41

» Our NHS
by Whiskers 29/6/2017, 16:49

Top posting users this month

Top posters

Kitkat (3396)
Whiskers (1212)
Stardust (1188)
Feather (1081)
Umberto Cocopop (369)
bimbow (313)
Jamboree (295)
lar-lar (132)
Pixie (105)
Curious (77)

Please sign our Guest Book


Top posting users this week

Exploring the mysteries of
life, death .... and beyond

to Light After Life forum
(Requires separate membership & login)

New address for Light After Life:

The girl who gets gifts from birds


Posts : 3396
Points : 12298
Join date : 2011-03-19
Location : Around the bend

The girl who gets gifts from birds

Post by Kitkat on 26/2/2015, 12:37

Lots of people love the birds in their garden, but it's rare for that affection to be reciprocated. One young girl in Seattle is luckier than most. She feeds the crows in her garden - and they bring her gifts in return.

She didn't gather this collection. Each item was a gift - given to her by crows.

Umberto Cocopop
Seasoned Member
Seasoned Member

Posts : 369
Points : 3295
Join date : 2011-10-18

Re: The girl who gets gifts from birds

Post by Umberto Cocopop on 26/2/2015, 16:42

It looks more like it's dumping its rubbish to me!

It might be feng shuiing its nest.

Posts : 3396
Points : 12298
Join date : 2011-03-19
Location : Around the bend

Re: The girl who gets gifts from birds

Post by Kitkat on 10/3/2015, 18:51

More on this story - and other similar stories:

from   link

Birds that bring gifts and do the gardening

Lynn Witte with crow Sheryl perched on her shoulder

A recent Magazine story reported how an eight-year-old girl in the US regularly receives gifts from crows - they seem to be thanking her for feeding them. It inspired readers to email us with details of their own remarkable relationships with birds.

In the original story Gabi Mann explained how crows have brought her a hoard of presents including coloured glass, paper clips, buttons and pieces of jewellery. It turns out she isn't the only person to receive gifts from wild birds.

Lynn Witte, US (above): I am the adopted mother of a baby crow that had been injured. I affectionately call her Sheryl Crow. I interacted with her constantly, hand fed her, encouraged her recovery and in the process I fell in love with this beautiful and intelligent creature. Over the summer she grew and eventually she learned to fly. Sheryl brings me gifts. My first was presented to me with her wings splayed open and head bowed. I was very ceremoniously handed a yellow foam dart from a toy gun! She refused to take the dart back as she does when we play games. I felt truly honoured. She has continued to surprise me with gifts that she finds.

Lynn's crow Sheryl plays with a small Santa Claus figurine

A Santa figurine was a gift that she brought to me. Sheryl usually brings bottle caps, screws, fishing bobbers, even a feather from a bird - never food or dead animals. When she brings them she spreads her wings completely and bows her head. Sheryl loves eggs, cheese, bacon, hamburgers, potatoes, blueberries, watermelon, peas and carrots - just about everything. Sheryl also likes to play games - she loves to hide rocks and shiny objects.

Sheryl Crow When Sheryl was bitten by a dog, Lynn took her to the vet for treatment

Katie Ross, Mukilteo, Washington, US: I feed our backyard crows every day. When they get something they really love, like leftover ribs with bits of meat still on them, I often find a gift on our porch railing. We've received everything from shiny polished rocks from our neighbour's landscaping to bright red bits of yarn to dead bugs. We love our crows!

Alex Fischer, Santa Fe, New Mexico, US: Years ago I was regularly putting out food for a raven. One day it brought me the small wooden handle of a tool, perhaps a small chisel. I treasured the connection, and still have the little wooden handle.

Alison Alcoba, Seattle, Washington, US: I have a collection of bits from our crows - toys mostly: a smashed Hot Wheels car, a plastic toy spinning top, a bright Cracker Jack token, a Donald Duck PEZ dispenser head, all left for us in the bird bath. We feed our crows peanuts, and our cat Black Bart used to play with the local crows. When Bart was killed by a coyote one early morning, it was the distress call of the crows that alerted us to what was left of his body. A week to the day after Bart died, we were awakened by a similar racket. When we went outside to see what the noise was about, there were about 40 crows in our yard, and below them, right on the spot where we found Bart's body the week before, was the collar he had been wearing, complete with name tag. That was the kindest gift of all and it gave us closure.

A toy Hot Wheels car, part of a yellow spinning top from Cracker Jack, a green plastic Donald Duck head most likely from a PEZ dispenser, a broken plastic tube used for single long-stemmed roses, and the collar worn by our cat Bart

Amethyst Selma-Selene, Stockport: On two occasions I had lost an item of jewellery that was important to me and weeks later I was given it back by magpies, members of the crow family. I bought this beautiful Victorian pentacle from America and I had it just one week before I lost it. Three weeks later, on a Sunday morning, I was off to my little shop when three magpies started to swoop down at me chattering loudly. Then they swooped down on to the road near the edge of the pavement. This went on for about three minutes until I stepped out on to the road to try and avoid the magpies' behaviour. It was then I noticed something shining on the road. And there was my Victorian pentacle on the road. They were showing me where it was, and I was amazed to find it again.

Silver necklace - a circle with a star inside

The pentacle earring, I lost a few months ago. I was going to put my dustbin out for collection but waited because the magpies were feeding. When they left I walked down the path and there it was.

Earring with round pendant engraved with a star

I have Mr Elliott who is a crow and lives with me. He was injured as a baby and only has sight in one eye. He will be two around May and he has been with me since he was seven or eight weeks old.

Crow named Mr Elliott as a young bird Mr Elliott

Guenther Lenske, Germany: I raised a baby crow from May 2013 to September 2014. When I got him he could not fly due to broken wing feathers so I kept him in a big cage in the garden directly by my bedroom window and let him out in the garden every day. It took about a year for the broken feathers to be replaced by new, stronger ones enabling him to fly. Before he left, he put a few little stones in my living room.

Crow perched outside

Stephanie St James, Madeira Beach, Florida, US: I have a shop in a tourist area and a number of seabirds frequently come to my shop because I have rescued a few. There was a crow that showed up with a split bottom beak and I began to feed him. That was 7 years ago, and he and a number of others continue to show up.

Crow perched on a chair on a deck above the water

I recently moved very close to my shop location and they found me at home as well. That is when the gifts started to arrive. The first was a piece of candy in a wrapper, and it was dropped in front of me. Then just a wrapper, bolts, shells and some bones arrived.

A lifesaver in a wrapper, a small shell, a screw and a caramel wrapper

Rick Zevering, Mountshannon, Co Clare, Ireland: In 1994, in Leusden, Holland, where I lived, I found a young crow that had fallen out of the nest. I named the crow Gorre, and he soon became a rather dominant member of my household. He was extremely jealous of just about anybody touching me or even talking to me. He had a very obvious sense of humour - pulling loose my shoelaces while I was reading the newspaper then quickly hiding behind a cupboard or sneaking up on the cats from behind while they were eating. He would hack them viciously in the tail which made them flee and then help himself to the cat food. Gorre adored me and gave me presents all the time. Mostly in the form of cat food that he had stolen, but occasionally he would bring me a stone, the lid of a milk bottle, a feather, a big live beetle and small branches or leaves.

Rick Zevering with his crow perched on his hand

He would fly into the house, land on my leg and he would then deposit his gift in my outstretched hand. This happened so frequently that I decided to put down a tray on a cupboard where all the items were kept. If I asked him to put it in the tray he would fly over to the cupboard and very meticulously place his latest gift among the others. Next door to us they were barbecuing and he landed on the barbecue, stole a sausage and brought it straight back to me, an act that caused some tension between the neighbours and us. Eventually more neighbours started to complain about Gorre. He would sit in front of a car at the parking lot and refuse to leave, or he would attack the neighbours' cats. It was with pain in my heart that I eventually had to move him to a forest 10km away. I never saw him again.

Edna King, Pfaffing, Bavaria, Germany: About 12 years ago when I was tending the vegetables in the garden, a very nosy and very big crow started to hang about. I called him Jakob and gave him some bread and cat food. Jakob soon came regularly for his meals and for "observing" me, as I like to describe it. When I finished weeding, I had the habit of tearing the bits very small. One day, I removed some bad leaves from the zucchini plant, Jakob ran as fast as he could towards me, ripped these leaves with his beak and his claws to tiny bits. He stomped on the shreds and croaked while doing this and he continued doing so with every leaf I pulled out. On some days he worked like a shredder. So my gift from Jakob was his help. It was a wonderful and also very hilarious gift.

Close up of perched crow and person stroking its back

Diane Cooper, High Wycombe: Many years ago, while on holiday in a cottage in Kent with our cousin (then about five), we noticed a crow-type bird visiting. It paid particular interest to my cousin (we think because of her high pitched voice). It followed her every day, accepted food from her hand and was photographed on her shoulder. One day she was sat on her bed when it landed on the open window sill and dropped a shiny coin on to her bed. We worked out afterwards that the bird was a jackdaw. Sadly we never saw it again on any other visit to this family cottage but then our cousin never visited again.

Michael Ostrogorsky, Seattle, US: Our Greenwing macaw parrot Roxanne has a set of crow friends who visit daily. They eat our cast-off parrot food we put out for them. On occasion I will find trinkets such as bottle caps and bent nails on the back porch steps.

Two crows perched on fence near red macaw on a tree

Kimberly Niemaseck, Kathmandu, Nepal: A new batch of baby crows was born and started visiting my balcony. I would feed them from time to time. Soon one became a regular and would call for me from the railing. I would always run and bring whatever was in the house. Then one morning I woke up to a broken piece of a shiny red glass bangle, commonly found on the streets of Kathmandu, but not three stories up on a balcony railing. I knew it had to be from the crow and I felt like a little girl showing it off to my friends. I saved it and had it lovingly on my dresser until I fell to the pressure of local friends who reminded me how broken red bangles were considered bad luck in the relationship department. I reluctantly got rid of it - if you knew my dating history you would understand.

A table with a picture frame, lamp and red bangle The red bangle is at the bottom of the photo, to left of the lamp
All Star Gold Member
All Star Gold Member

Posts : 1212
Points : 6401
Join date : 2011-04-02

Re: The girl who gets gifts from birds

Post by Whiskers on 11/3/2015, 22:00

These stories are so beautiful. flower

They can't all be doing Feng Shui, Umberto. drunken Something very deep and beautiful going on there.
Umberto Cocopop
Seasoned Member
Seasoned Member

Posts : 369
Points : 3295
Join date : 2011-10-18

Re: The girl who gets gifts from birds

Post by Umberto Cocopop on 12/3/2015, 13:24

Of course there's something going on. I'm just not convinced that it's intentional gift bringing as a way of saying thanks.

It's more likely to be a variation on their normal behaviour. You can read up on BF Skinner and his work with pigeons to see how 'operant conditioning' can affect their behaviour patterns.

It may not even be that. The correlation could easily be illusory.

How many times do crows come to feed and not bring 'gifts'? Is this cherry picking the positive examples?

Perhaps, as crows seem to collect items as a part of their normal behaviour, carrying something to a place where they get fed could simply result in them putting it down to feed and then leaving it behind as a consequence. Leaving humans to assume it was intentional.

I don't know the answer; but ascribing human levels of cognition to a bird, I would suggest, is the least likely answer.
Seasoned Member
Seasoned Member

Posts : 295
Points : 3535
Join date : 2011-06-08

Re: The girl who gets gifts from birds

Post by Jamboree on 15/3/2015, 05:47

Crows are surprisingly intelligent creatures.

Have a look at this.  

    Current date/time is 24/3/2018, 08:16